Appendix 2 – Technical Information and Calibration of the Physical Test Equipment
Clasification Society 2024 - Version 9.40
Statutory Documents - IMO Publications and Documents - International Codes - 2010 FTP Code – International Code for Application of Fire Test Procedures, 20101 – Resolution MSC.307(88) - Annex 1 – Fire Test Procedures - Part 5 – Test for Surface Flammability (Test for Surface Materials and Primary Deck Covering) - Appendix 2 – Technical Information and Calibration of the Physical Test Equipment

Appendix 2 – Technical Information and Calibration of the Physical Test Equipment

 This appendix provides technical information intended to permit construction, erection, alignment and calibration of the physical equipment required for the conduct of tests by this procedure.

1 Test Equipment Fabrication

 Figures 1 and 2 show photographs of the equipment as assembled, ready for test. The test apparatus, except the equipment for measurement of heat release (i.e. fume stack and thermocouples for it), is specified in standard ISO 5658-2.

  1.1 Brief parts list for the test equipment assembly includes:

  • .1 the main frame (figure 1) which comprises two separate sections, the burner frame and the specimen support frame. These two units are bolted together with threaded rods permitting flexibility in mechanical alignment;

  • .2 specimen holders which provide for support of the specimens during test. At least two of these are required. Three prevent delays resulting from required cooling of holders prior to mounting specimens;

  • .3 a specimen fume stack fabricated of stainless steel sheet of 0.5 ± 0.05 mm thickness complete with gas and stack metal compensating thermocouples;

  • .4 the radiant panel which has radiating surface dimensions of 280 mm x 483 mm. It has been specially fabricated for use with this equipment through use of commercially-available porous refractory tiles;

  • .5 the blower for combustion air supply, radiant panel, air flow metering device, gas control valves, pressure reducer and safety controls which are all mounted on the burner frame. Requirements are summarized below:

    • .1 air supply of about 30 m3/h at a pressure sufficient to overcome the friction losses through the line, metering device and radiant panel. The radiant panel drop amounts to only a few millimetres of water; and

    • .2 the gas used may be either natural gas, methane or propane-butane. The use of gas other than methane or natural gas is not recommendedfootnote, although with changes in panel-specimen spacing, it is possible to use the equipment with propane at flux levels of 50 kW/m2. A pressure regulator shall be provided to maintain a constant supply pressure. Gas is controlled by a manually adjusted needle valve. No venturi mixer is necessary. Safety devices include an electrically-operated shutoff valve to prevent gas flow in the event of electric power failure, air pressure failure and loss of heat at the burner surface. The gas flow requirements are roughly 1.0 m3/h to 3.7 m3/h for natural gas or methane at a pressure to overcome line pressure losses;

  • .6 the specimen holder, pilot flame holder, fume stack, flame front viewing rakes, radiation pyrometer and mirror are all assembled on the specimen support frame. The arrangement of parts on this frame is shown in figures 1 and 2; and

  • .7 a dummy specimen as defined in paragraph 3.5 of appendix 1 to this part shall be continuously mounted on the apparatus in the position of the specimen during operation of the equipment. This dummy specimen should only be removed when a test specimen is to be inserted.

2 Instrumentation

2.1 Total radiation pyrometer

 This should have a sensitivity substantially constant between the thermal wave lengths of 1 m and 9 m and should view a centrally-located area on the panel of about 150 mm x 300 mm. The instrument should be mounted on the specimen support frame in such a manner that it can view the panel surface.

2.2 Heat flux meters

  2.2.1 It is desirable to have at least three heat flux meters for this test method. They should be of the thermopile type with a nominal range of 0 kW/m2 to 50 kW/m2 and capable of safe operation at three times this rating.

  2.2.2 The heat flux meters shall be calibrated in accordance with standard ISO 14934-3, Fire tests – Calibration and use of heat flux meters – Part 3: Secondary calibration method. Two of these should be retained as a laboratory reference standard. They should have been calibrated to an accuracy of within ± 5%.

  2.2.3 The target sensing of the applied flux should occupy an area not more than 80 mm2 and be located flush with and at the centre of the water-cooled 25 mm circular exposed metallic end of the heat flux meter. If heat flux meters of smaller diameter are to be used, these should be inserted into a copper sleeve of 25 mm outside diameter in such a way that good thermal contact is maintained between the sleeve and water-cooled heat flux meter body. The end of the sleeve and the exposed surface of the heat flux meter should lie in the same plane. Radiation should not pass through any window before reaching the target.

2.3 Timing devices

 Both a chronograph and either an electric clock with a sweep second hand or a digital clock should be provided to measure time of ignition and flame advance. The chronograph for timing ignition and initial flame advance may comprise a strip chart recorder with paper speed of at least 5 mm/s and an event marker pen. Both the chronograph paper drive and the electric clock should be operated through a common switch to initiate simultaneous operation when the specimen is exposed. This may be either hand operated or actuated automatically as a result of complete specimen insertion.

2.4 Recording millivoltmeter

 A two-channel strip chart recording millivoltmeter having at least one megohm input resistance should be used to record signals from the fume stack thermocouples and the output from the radiation pyrometer. The signal from the fume stack will in most instances be less than 15 mV but in some cases this may be exceeded by a small amount. The sensitivity of the other channel should be selected to require less than full scale deflection with the total radiation pyrometer or flux meter chosen. The effective operating temperature of the radiant panel should not normally exceed 935°C.

2.5 Digital voltmeter

 A small digital millivoltmeter will be found convenient for monitoring changes in operating conditions of the radiant panel. It should be capable of indicating signal changes of 10 μV or less.

3 Space for conducting Tests

3.1 Special room

 A special room should be provided for the performance of this test. The dimensions of it are not critical but it may be roughly 45 m3 volume with a ceiling height of not less than 2.5 m.

3.2 Fume exhaust system

 An exhaust system should be installed above the ceiling with a capacity for moving air and combustion products at a rate of 30 m3/min. The ceiling grille opening to this exhaust system should be surrounded by a 1.3 m x 1.3 m refractory fibre fabric skirt hanging from the ceiling down to 1.7 ± 0.1 m from the floor of the room. The specimen support frame and radiant panel should be located beneath this hood in such a way that all combustion fumes are withdrawn from the room.

3.3 The apparatus

 This should be located with a clearance of at least 1 m separation between it and the walls of the test room. No combustible finish material of ceiling, floor or walls should be located within 2 m of the radiant heat source.

3.4 Air supply

 Access to an exterior supply of air, to replace that removed by the exhaust system, is required. This should be arranged in such a way that the ambient temperature remains reasonably stable (for example: the air might be taken from an adjoining heated building).

3.5 Room draughts

 Measurements should be made of air speeds near a dummy specimen while the fume exhaust system is operating but the radiant panel and its air supply are turned off. At a distance of 100 mm the air flow perpendicular to the lower edge at midlength of the specimen should not exceed 0.2 m/s in any direction.

4 Assembly and Adjustment

4.1 General

 The test conditions are essentially defined in terms of the measured heat flux incident on a dummy specimen during calibration. Radiation transfer will predominate, but convection transfer will also play a part. The flux level incident at the specimen surface is a result of the geometrical configuration between the radiant panel and the specimen, as well as the thermal output from the radiant panel.

  4.1.1 Both in original adjustment of test operating conditions and periodic verification of this adjustment, the measured heat flux at the surface of the specimen is the controlling criterion. This heat flux is measured by a heat flux meter (see paragraph 2.2 above) mounted in a special dummy specimen (see figure 11).

  4.1.2 Between consecutive tests, the operating level should be monitored either by use of a heat flux meter mounted in a dummy specimen as defined in paragraph 3.5 of appendix 1 under "Definitions" or preferably by use of a radiation pyrometer which has been previously periodically calibrated on the basis of the readings of such a heat flux meter. This radiation pyrometer should be rigidly fixed to the specimen-holder frame in such a manner that it continuously views the radiating panel surface (see paragraph 2.1).

4.2 Mechanical alignment

  4.2.1 Most of the adjustments of the components of the test apparatus may be conducted in the cold condition. The position of the refractory surface of the radiant panel with respect to the specimen must correspond with the dimensions shown in figure 3.

  4.2.2 These relationships can be achieved by appropriate use of shims between the panel and its mounting bracket, adjustment of separation between the two main frames, and adjustment of the position of the specimen holder guides. Detailed procedures for making these adjustments are suggested in paragraph 5.

  4.2.3 The fume stack for heat release measurements should be mechanically mounted on the specimen support frame in the position shown in figure 4.

  4.2.4 The method of mounting should ensure the relative positions shown and should allow easy stack removal for cleaning and/or repair. The compensating thermocouple should be mounted in such a manner that good thermal contact is achieved while ensuring greater than one megohm electrical resistance from the stack metal wall.

4.3 Thermal adjustment of panel operating level

  4.3.1 Thermal adjustment of the panel operating level is achieved by first setting an air flow of about 30 m3/h through the panel. Gas is then supplied and the panel ignited and allowed to come to thermal equilibrium with a dummy specimen mounted before it. At proper operating condition, there should be no visible flaming from the panel surface except when viewed from one side parallel to the surface plane. From this direction, a thin blue flame very close to the panel surface will be observed. An oblique view of the panel after a 15 min warm-up period should show a bright orange radiating surface.

  4.3.2 With a water-cooled heat flux meter mounted in the calibration board, the measured incident heat flux on the specimen should correspond to the values shown in table 1. Compliance with this requirement is achieved by adjustment of the gas flow. If necessary, small changes in air flow can be made to achieve the condition of no significant flaming from the panel surface. Precise duplication of the flux measurements specified in table 1 for the 50 mm and 350 mm positions on the basis of the heat flux meter calibration used will fix the flux at the other stations well within the limits called for. This does not mean that all other flux levels are correct, but it does ensure that a fixed configuration or view geometry between the panel and specimen has been achieved. To meet these requirements, it may be necessary to make small changes in the specimen longitudinal position shown in figure 6. A plot and smooth curve should be developed on the basis of the eight flux measurements required. The shape of the curve should be similar to that defined by the typical data shown in table 1. These measurements are important, since the experimental results are reported on the basis of these flux measurements. If a total radiation pyrometer is to be used to monitor panel operation, records of its signal should be kept following successful completion of this calibration procedure. If a change in panel-specimen axial position is necessary to meet the requirements for flux at the 50 mm and 350 mm positions, this should be accomplished by adjusting the screws connecting the two frames. In this way, the pilot position with respect to the specimen will remain unchanged. The specimen stop screw adjustment may be changed to meet the flux requirements in the standard and then the position of the pilot burner mount may require adjustment to maintain the 10 ± 2 mm pilot spacing.

  4.3.3 Water cooling of the heat flux meter is required to avoid erroneous signals at low flux levels. The temperature of the cooling water should be controlled in such a manner that the heat flux meter body temperature remains within a few degrees of room temperature. If this is not done, correction of the flux measurement should be made for temperature difference between the heat flux meter body and room temperature. Failure to supply water-cooling may result in thermal damage to the thermal sensing surface and loss of calibration of the heat flux meter. In some cases repairs and recalibration are possible.

  4.3.4 Once these operating conditions have been achieved, all future panel operation should take place with the established air flow with gas supply as the variable to achieve the specimen flux level as calibrated. This level should be monitored with use of either a radiation pyrometer fixed to view an area of the source surface or a heat flux meter mounted in a dummy specimen, as defined in paragraph 3.5 of appendix 1 – (Definitions), at the 350 mm position. If the latter method is used, the assembly of dummy specimen and heat flux meter should remain in place between tests.

4.4 Adjustments and calibrations – general

 The following adjustments and calibrations are to be achieved by burning methane gas from the line heat source located parallel to, and in the same plane as, the centreline of a dummy specimen located in position and without heat flux meters. This line burner comprises a 2 m length of pipe of 9.1 mm internal diameter. One end is closed off with a cap and a line of 15 holes of 3 mm diameter are drilled at 16 mm spacing through the pipe wall. The gas burned as it flows through this line of vertically positioned holes flames up through the stack. The measured flow rate and the net or lower heat of combustion of the gas serve to produce a known heat release rate which can be observed as a compensated stack millivolt signal change. Prior to performing calibration tests, measurements must be conducted to verify that the stack thermocouple compensation has been properly adjusted.

4.5 Compensation adjustment

  4.5.1 The fraction of the signal from the compensator thermocouple which is subtracted from the stack thermocouple output should be adjusted by means of the resistance of one leg of the potential divider shown in figure 7.

  4.5.2 The purpose of this adjustment is, as far as practical, to eliminate from the stack signal the long-term signal changes resulting from the relatively slow stack metal temperature variations. Figure 8 shows the curves resulting from under-compensation, correct compensation, and over-compensation. These curves were obtained by abruptly placing the lighted gas calibration burner adjacent to the hot end of a dummy specimen and then extinguishing it. For this adjustment, the calibration gas feed rate should be set to correspond to a heat rate of 1 kW. The compensator potential divider should be adjusted to yield curves that show a rapid rise to a steady state signal which is essentially constant over a 5 min period following the first minute of transient signal rise. When the calibration burner is shut off, the signal should rapidly decrease and reach a steady state value within 2 min.

 Following this, there should be no long-term rise or fall of the signal. Experience has shown that between 40% and 50% of the compensation thermocouple signal should be included in the output signal to achieve this condition. When properly adjusted, a square thermal pulse of 7 kW should show not more than approximately 7% overshoot shortly after application of the calibration flame (see figure 8).

4.6 Fume stack calibration

 With the adjustment described in paragraph 4.5 completed and a steady state base signal having been achieved, stack calibration should be carried out with the radiant panel operating at 50.5 kW/m2 and the pilot burner not lit. The calibration of the stack millivolt signal rise should be made by introducing and removing the line burner, as described in paragraph 4.4. The flow rate of methane gas of at least 95% purity should be varied over the range of about 0.004 m3/min to 0.02 m3/min in sufficient increments to permit plotting the data in a well defined curve of stack compensated millivolt signal rise against the net or lower heat input rate. A similar calibration should be performed with the calibration burner located at the cool end of the specimen. The two curves should show agreement in indicated heat release rate within about 15%. A typical curve is shown in figure 9. The curve for the calibration burner at the hot end of the specimen should be the one used for reporting all heat release measurements. This completes the calibration and the test equipment is ready for use.

5 Assembly and Mechanical Adjustment of the Flammability Test Apparatus

 The radiant panel subassembly has been completed with the exception of the support brackets and reverberatory screen. The equipment can be assembled to permit test of specimens of thickness up to 50 mm.

  5.1 The panel frame should be placed upright on a level floor, preferably in the location in which the equipment will be used.

  5.2 The rotating ring should be mounted on its three guide bearings.

  5.3 The panel mount frame should be bolted together, and to the ring, by four bolts.

  5.4 A check should be made that the ring lies in a vertical plane. If the error is large, an adjustment of the upper ring support-bearing location may be necessary. Prior to making such an adjustment, it should be determined whether the error is due to excessive clearance between the ring and bearing rollers. If this is the case, rollers of a larger diameter may correct the problem.

  5.5 The four panel support brackets should be fastened to the radiant panel at the four corners. Do not use too much force in bolting these brackets in place. Prior to mounting these brackets, one 35 mm M9 cap screw is placed in the hole that will be farthest from the panel end. These screws provide a means for mounting the panel.

  5.6 Four washers should be placed on each of the panel mounting screws and the panel assembled on the mount bracket.

  5.7 The angularity of the radiant panel surface with the plane of the mounting ring should be checked. This can be accomplished by means of a carpenter's square and measurements to the refractory tile surface at both ends of the panel. Any deviation from the required 15° angle may be adjusted by increasing or reducing the number of washers on the mounting screws.

  5.8 The radiant panel should be rotated to face a specimen mounted in a vertical plane.

  5.9 The panel surface should be checked with a spirit level to ensure that it also lies in a vertical plane.

  5.10 The specimen frame with specimen support rails on the side and bottom positions and the pilot burner holder assembled in approximate positions should be brought up to the burner frame and the two frames fastened together with two bolts and six nuts or two threaded rods and eight nuts. The spacing between the frames is roughly 125 mm.

  5.11 The spacing of the two sides of the frames is adjusted to ensure that the specimen support frame longitudinal members are at a 15° angle to the radiant panel surface.

  5.12 The single specimen holder side guide rail for vertical specimen orientation should be adjusted so that it is at the required 15° angle to the radiant panel surface.

  5.13 An empty specimen holder should be slid into position on the rail and the position of the upper guide fork adjusted to ensure that when a specimen is inserted in the holder its surface will lie in a vertical plane.

  5.14 The stop screw determining the axial position of the specimen holder should be adjusted to ensure that the axis of the pilot burner is 10 ± 2 mm from the closest exposed edge of the specimen. This adjustment should again be made by use of an empty specimen holder and substitution of a 6 mm steel rod of 250 mm length for the pilot burner ceramic tube. When viewed from the back of the specimen holder, the spacing between rod axis and the edge of the specimen retaining flange of the holder should be 10 ± 2 mm.

  5.15 With the specimen holder still in place against the stop screw, the spacing between the panel and specimen support frames should be adjusted to make dimension B (see figure 3) equal to approximately 125 mm. This adjustment is made by means of the two screws fastening the frames together. In making this adjustment, it is important to make equal adjustments on each side to maintain the angular relationship called for in adjustments in paragraphs 5.11 and 5.12.

  5.16 The nuts supporting the specimen holder side guide rail should be adjusted to ensure that dimension A (see figure 3) is 125 ± 2 mm. Again, equal adjustments to the two mounting points are required. When doing this, a check should be made to ensure that the guide rail and edge of the specimen holder are in a horizontal plane. In making this adjustment, it is important to ensure that the 45 mm stack position dimension, as shown in figure 4, is maintained. Another way of adjustment to dimension A is through changes in the number of washers mentioned in paragraph 5.6.

  5.17 If necessary, the procedure described in paragraph 5.13 should be repeated.

  5.18 The reverberatory screen should be mounted on the radiant panel. This must be done in such a manner that it is free to expand as it heats up during operation.

  5.19 The viewing rake with 50 mm pins is mounted on an angle fastened to the specimen holder guide rail. Its position is adjusted so that pins are located at multiples of 50 mm distance from the closest end of the specimen exposed to the panel. It should be clamped in this position.

Table 1 – Calibration of incident heat flux to the specimen
Distance from exposed end of the specimen (mm) Typical flux levels at the specimen (kW/m2) Calibration position to be used (kW/m2)
0 49.5  
50 50.5 50.5
100 49.5  
150 47.1 x
200 43.1  
250 37.8 x
300 30.9  
350 23.9 23.9
400 18.2  
450 13.2 x
500 9.2  
550 6.2 x
600 4.3  
650 3.1 x
700 2.2  
750 1.5 x

 Typical flux incident on the specimen and specimen positions at which the calibration measurements are to be made. The flux at the 50 mm and 350 mm positions should agree with the typical values within 5%. Calibration data at other positions should agree with typical values within 10%.

 Two sets of thermocouples (T.C.) and lead wires are required. The wire size and lengths within the fume T.C. group must be the same to ensure proper signal averaging. The parallel connection of the couples may be achieved at the mixing box by plug connection of the leads. This allows quick removal and checks for continuity and grounding problems with minimum delay. No cold junction should be used but the signal mixing box should be shielded from panel radiation.


Copyright 2022 Clasifications Register Group Limited, International Maritime Organization, International Labour Organization or Maritime and Coastguard Agency. All rights reserved. Clasifications Register Group Limited, its affiliates and subsidiaries and their respective officers, employees or agents are, individually and collectively, referred to in this clause as 'Clasifications Register'. Clasifications Register assumes no responsibility and shall not be liable to any person for any loss, damage or expense caused by reliance on the information or advice in this document or howsoever provided, unless that person has signed a contract with the relevant Clasifications Register entity for the provision of this information or advice and in that case any responsibility or liability is exclusively on the terms and conditions set out in that contract.